A countertop ice maker plugs in, takes a pour of water, and starts making ice in minutes — no plumbing needed. Bullet-ice makers are the cheapest and fastest, while nugget ice makers make the soft, chewable ice many people love from restaurants. Most countertop models don't keep ice frozen; melted ice drains back into the tank to be remade. We compared popular ice makers on ice type, speed, daily output, cleaning, and value. Quick rule: run the cleaning cycle every couple of weeks, and use filtered water to cut down on scale.
Compare all 5 picks at a glance
- 1
9.2/10Check PriceBest Overall
Silonn Nugget Ice Maker Countertop with Carry Handle (36 lbs/Day)Best for nugget ice fans
- 29.0/10Check Price

- 3
8.9/10Check PriceBest Upgrade Pick
Euhomy Upgraded Countertop Nugget Ice Maker (35 lbs/Day)Best for kitchens that want the best nugget ice maker
- 48.7/10Check Price

- 5
8.4/10Check PriceFastest Cubes
Silonn Countertop Ice Maker (10 Cubes in 5 Minutes)
Best for quick ice for drinks
Our top 4 picks, reviewed
Best Overall
Silonn Nugget Ice Maker Countertop with Carry Handle (36 lbs/Day)
Best for: nugget ice fans
Soft, chewable "Sonic-style" nugget ice at home for a fraction of premium prices — first ice in about 5 minutes, with self-cleaning.
What we like
- Chewable nugget ice people love
- Over 30,000 Amazon reviews
- Self-cleaning and easy to carry
Watch out for
- Needs regular descaling
- Basket holds less than a day's output
Best Value
FRIGIDAIRE Compact Countertop Ice Maker (26 lbs/Day)
Best for: everyday drinks on a budget
A compact bullet-ice maker from a trusted appliance brand — fresh ice in minutes for a low price.
What we like
- Trusted appliance brand
- Low price
- Over 16,000 Amazon reviews
Watch out for
- Bullet ice melts faster
- Ice isn't kept frozen
Best Upgrade Pick
Euhomy Upgraded Countertop Nugget Ice Maker (35 lbs/Day)
Best for: kitchens that want the best nugget ice maker
A fast, upgraded nugget ice maker for chewable restaurant-style ice at a mid-range price.
What we like
- Soft, chewable nugget ice
- Fast first batch
- Over 13,000 Amazon reviews
Watch out for
- Needs regular cleaning
- Takes counter space
Best High Output
EUHOMY Nugget Ice Maker Countertop (44 lbs/Day)
Best for: big families and parties
A high-output nugget ice maker that makes up to 44 lbs a day — enough for big families and frequent entertaining.
What we like
- Up to 44 lbs of ice a day
- Self-cleaning
- Mid-range price
Watch out for
- Louder than smaller models
- Takes more counter space
Also worth considering
Strong alternatives that fit specific needs or budgets.

Silonn Countertop Ice Maker (10 Cubes in 5 Minutes)
8.4/10A quick, low-cost bullet-ice maker with a self-cleaning cycle and over 30,000 reviews.
Check Price on AmazonHow we picked
We compare specifications, safety features, warranty terms, and brand support, then look for patterns across thousands of verified owner reviews — especially long-term reliability complaints. Scores are our own editorial ratings out of 10. Brands can't pay to be included or ranked higher. Read our full process
You might also need




Best Mattresses 2026
Sleep better without overpaying. 5 mattresses compared — memory foam, hybrid, premium, name-brand foam, and budget beds in a box.
Our pick: Zinus 12 Inch Green Tea Memory Foam Mattress (Medium Firm)
See the full ranking



Best Air Fryers 2026
Crispy food with little or no oil. 5 air fryers compared — top basket models, dual-basket, value, toaster oven combos, and compact budget picks.
Our pick: COSORI TurboBlaze Air Fryer (6 Qt, 9-in-1, Ceramic Coating)
See the full ranking



Best Microwaves 2026
Reheat, defrost, and cook faster. 5 microwaves compared — full-size, inverter, air fryer combo, value, and compact picks.
Our pick: TOSHIBA Countertop Microwave Oven (1.2 Cu. Ft., 1000W, Smart Sensor)
See the full ranking